Atlantic Herring and Similar Species
Clupea
Got a photo? Identify fish instantly with the Fishby app.
Open the appSeveral fish can be confused with Atlantic Herring. Here are the key differences.
Species often confused with {name}
Sardine (Pilchard)
Sardina pilchardus (European Pilchard), Sardinops sagax (Pacific Sardine)
Key differences: Sardines generally have a more rounded body, often with small dark spots along the flanks (though not always). Their scales are typically smaller and less easily shed than herring. Sardines also tend to be smaller on average than adult Atlantic Herring.
Sprat (Brisling)
Sprattus sprattus
Key differences: Sprats are smaller than herring (typically 10-16 cm). They have a more pronounced, sharp keel of scutes along their belly, which feels rougher to the touch than a herring's. The dorsal fin origin is slightly further back than the pelvic fin origin in sprats, whereas in herring, they are aligned.
Shad
Alosa spp.
Key differences: Shad species (e.g., American Shad, Alosa sapidissima) are generally deeper-bodied and more compressed laterally than herring. They often have a series of dark spots behind the operculum and a more prominent, sharper ventral keel of scutes. Shad are also typically larger than herring.
Menhaden
Brevoortia spp.
Key differences: Menhaden are deeper-bodied and more compressed than herring, with a very large head and mouth. They have a distinctive large, dark spot behind the operculum and a very prominent, serrated keel of scutes along the belly. Their scales are also larger and more easily shed than herring.
Pacific Herring
Clupea pallasii
Key differences: While very similar morphologically to Atlantic Herring, Pacific Herring are a distinct species found in the North Pacific. Differentiation often requires genetic analysis or precise meristic counts (e.g., vertebral counts), though their geographic distribution is the primary distinguishing factor for field identification.
Explore Atlantic Herring
Identify fish anywhere
Free on iOS, Android, and Web. Photo identification, full species details, and more.